Stray Dog

Tesla: California subsidy snapped up, China sales crown lost

  • Bad news: Geely's Xingyuan, at about a third of the price, took China's sales crown and pushed Model Y to second.
  • Bad news: California's subsidy allocation was claimed in 5 days and sales jumped, which shows sales driven by subsidies, not a real recovery.
  • Bad news: An NHTSA recall covers 20,349 Model 3 and Model Y cars with headlights that are too bright.
Read the full notes

Tesla used up California's MyFirstEV subsidy in 5 days and its sales jumped week on week (confirmed by CARB), which confirms that car sales are being driven by subsidies and promotions rather than a genuine recovery in demand. In China, the Geely Xingyuan took the sales crown at about 1/3 of the price, pushing Model Y into second place.

Read more

Price-war leadership has spread from BYD to Geely, and with no low-priced model to compete, Tesla faces a deepening structural headwind. A physical NHTSA recall covers 20,349 Model 3 and Model Y cars whose headlights are too bright (26V507, supplier Marelli), adding to the quality-control noise from Fremont. FSD (Supervised) has launched in Switzerland, one more country in Europe's step-by-step rollout (incremental, not a catalyst). TSLA is up about 4% over 5 days but still down 26% this year, at a forward P/E of about 347x. Fundamentals (Q2 automotive gross margin 16.3%, operating margin 1.4%, negative FCF) remain detached from a share price propped up by long-dated AI optionality.

Key evidence

  • California's MyFirstEV first-time buyer subsidy ($3,500 on a new car) went live on 3 Aug. Tesla's allocation was fully claimed within 5 days, with 50% claimed in the first 3 days (Sawyer Merritt's count)
  • CARB spokesperson Buckley formally confirmed that the 'referenced car company' is Tesla, and that Tesla reported a sharp week-on-week jump in sales to the state after the subsidy went live
  • The subsidy's price cap excludes Rivian and Lucid but not Tesla, meaning Tesla's cars are cheaper
  • Background: the $7,500 federal EV credit expired in September 2025, and EV demand has weakened across the US
  • China passenger car sales ranking (Autohome/Seeking Alpha, 6 months to July): the Geely Xingyuan took first place and Model Y slipped to second
  • Price gap: the Xingyuan starts below RMB 100,000 (about $14,820), while Model Y costs RMB 263,500 to RMB 313,500 (about 3 times the price)
Show 9 more
  • Several BYD models made the top 10, but its overall sales fell. It was the cheaper Geely Xingyuan, not BYD, that knocked Model Y off the top spot
  • NHTSA recall 26V507: 18,735 Model Y (2020-2023) and 1,614 Model 3 (2017-2023), 20,349 cars in total
  • Low-beam brightness exceeds the federal limit (as early as 2024 some models were found to be more than double the permitted level). The supplier is Marelli. This is a physical recall that needs a service visit, not an OTA fix
  • Quality-control noise from Fremont is building at the same time: an NHTSA investigation into front suspension links, and the admission on the Cybertruck PCS
  • On Thursday 13 Aug Tesla officially launched its first FSD (Supervised) ride-along demonstrations in Switzerland
  • This continues the country-by-country grind after the Netherlands, Denmark, Belgium and Norway, in parallel with the EU-wide vote on 6 Oct
  • TSLA is up about 4% over the last 5 trading days (heading for a 5th straight gain) but still down about 26% this year
  • Forward P/E about 347x; FSD take rate on new North American cars 55% (11 Aug data)
  • Most of the 28 analysts stay at Hold; Q2 automotive gross margin 16.3%, operating margin 1.4%, FCF negative

Catalysts to watch

  • Expiry of the $7,500 federal EV credit in September 2025: the demand vacuum once subsidies fade is the clearest window to watch
  • EU-wide vote on FSD (Supervised) on 6 Oct: single-country wins are incremental, and only EU-wide approval would be a catalyst
  • Low-priced Chinese rivals such as the Geely Xingyuan keep ramping up volume, the path by which Model Y's share in China keeps eroding

Risks

  • Demand: sales driven by subsidies and promotions, not a real recovery; risk of a sales cliff once the federal credit is gone
  • China: no low-priced model to take on the Geely Xingyuan ($14,820 against $37k-plus for Model Y); the structural headwind in the domestic market is deepening
  • Quality: the physical recall of Marelli headlights, on top of the front suspension link investigation and the Cybertruck PCS issue. Consistency flaws at Fremont are piling up
  • Valuation: a forward P/E of 347x against Q2 automotive gross margin of 16.3%, operating margin of 1.4% and negative FCF. Fundamentals are detached from a share price propped up by long-dated AI optionality

Sources 5

  1. Official confirmation from CARB spokesperson Buckley ('referenced car company' is Tesla)
  2. Sawyer Merritt's count of California subsidy claims
  3. Autohome and Seeking Alpha China passenger car sales ranking (6 months to July)
  4. NHTSA recall number 26V507
  5. Tesla announcement of the FSD (Supervised) launch in Switzerland (13 Aug)