Tesla keeps Cybercab compliance answers confidential
- Bad news: Tesla asked to keep all its answers to 21 NHTSA questions secret; Cybercab scaling depends on NHTSA accepting self-certification.
- Bad news: If NHTSA refuses, an exemption route would cap Cybercab at 2,500 vehicles a year and choke the production ramp.
- Mixed: Robotaxi's hailable area is 22-41% smaller than the official geofence, but population coverage is 83-89%.
Read the full notes
Scaling Cybercab depends on NHTSA accepting Tesla's self-certification. Tesla has asked for trade-secret treatment of all its answers to 21 special questions, and the only public part is the firefighter rescue manual. If NHTSA refuses and Tesla is pushed down a Zoox-style exemption route, the annual cap of 2,500 vehicles would choke the production ramp.
Read more
Add the Democrats taking both houses of Congress in the midterms, which makes congressional scrutiny of Tesla's autonomous-driving safety record more likely. That is a regulatory variable worth watching more closely than the share price. The Robotaxi area that can actually be hailed is 22-41% smaller than the official geofence, but population coverage is 83-89%, so the narrative should shift from square miles to people covered. Energy keeps delivering (the 250MW/500MWh Megapack in Canberra is online), Shanghai localisation has risen to 98%, and Cybercab was only shown in China, with no launch timetable.
Key evidence
- NHTSA docket AQ26002: Tesla filed its answers on 30 Oct and asked for the whole submission to be treated as a trade secret. It had asked for an 8-week extension to 20 Nov, but the regulator gave only 30 days. An incomplete answer can draw a fine of up to $139 million (Electrek, 5 Nov)
- The manual sets out Cybercab's design operating range: all public roads including motorways, all weather, and light to moderate rain, fog and snow, far beyond today's Austin geofence. Cybercabs fitted with a steering wheel and pedals are engineering or test vehicles and run at L2
- Robotaxi area that can actually be hailed vs the official geofence: Austin 160 of 273 square miles (59%), Houston 188 of 255 (74%), Fort Worth 105 of 144 (73%), Dallas 63 of 81 (78%). The figures come from community researcher Koby Pierce, who requested rides point by point in a simulator (Not a Tesla App, 5 Nov)
- Population coverage: Austin 83% of residents (about 675,000 of 809,000), Dallas 89%. The gaps are mostly parks, industrial areas and land along railway lines
- Williamsdale power station in Canberra: 136 Megapack 2 XL units, 250MW/500MWh, able to cover about a third of Canberra's electricity use for up to 2 hours, on time and on budget (ACT Government and Eku Energy, 5 Nov)
- Shanghai localisation has risen from 95% or more in 2022 to 98%. Part of the Model Y L seat design was developed jointly with Chinese suppliers. Cybercab was shown in China, but Tesla says it has no plan for sales or commercial operation yet (Drive Tesla, 5 Nov)
- Shanghai exports were about 49% of output in the first 9 months
Catalysts to watch
- NHTSA's final ruling on Cybercab self-certification. If it refuses or pushes Tesla towards the exemption process, the annual cap is 2,500 vehicles
- Democrats take both houses of Congress in the midterms (LA Times/USA Today, 5 Nov). Committees gain the power to hold hearings and demand documents, and the autonomous-driving safety record comes under congressional scrutiny
- How mature Tesla's launch playbook for new Robotaxi cities is: Austin is the oldest and has the lowest coverage, while coverage rises in newer cities
- Continued delivery in energy (Melbourne 1.6GWh, then Canberra 500MWh, then the Megapack foreign trade zone in Texas)
- A timetable for Cybercab in China (none at present)
Risks
- Regulatory risk: NHTSA rejects self-certification, Tesla is forced into the exemption process and output is held down by a hard cap
- Congressional risk: with both houses changing hands, hearing and document powers grow and the autonomous-driving safety record becomes politicised
- Information risk: the Koby Pierce data is third-party and unofficial, and Tesla has not confirmed it
- Narrative risk: once the square-mile figures are shown to be inflated, the market may reprice the city-expansion story
- China risk: no timetable for Cybercab in China and no path for Robotaxi to launch there
Sources 5
- Electrek (5 Nov): Cybercab NHTSA AQ26002 trade-secret answers
- Not a Tesla App (5 Nov): Koby Pierce analysis of actual Robotaxi coverage area
- ACT Government + Eku Energy (5 Nov): Williamsdale Megapack goes online
- Drive Tesla (5 Nov): Shanghai factory localisation at 98% and Cybercab shown at CIIE
- LA Times / USA Today (5 Nov): Democrats win both houses in the midterms