Stray Dog

Palantir: Poland Maven deal stalls, UK NHS lobbying revealed

  • Bad news: Poland's Maven contract is still unsigned after more than a year, with calls for an independent audit and a protest planned on 8 Nov.
  • Bad news: The UK NHS renewal looks driven by lobbying and politics, not product lock-in, with a real risk of churn within two years.
  • Bad news: International commercial revenue grew only 1% QoQ in Q3, the weakest leg of the thesis.
Read the full notes

Two incremental data points today, both on the international government line, and both reinforce the weakest part of the bull case: European political friction over sovereign data is turning into real contracting delays.

Read more

The Poland Maven Smart System deal has been under negotiation for more than a year (MOU in Dec 2024, LOI in Oct 2025, still no contract in Nov 2026). The defence minister cites 'weeks waiting on military analysis', yet Palantir representatives told the presidential team in New York in September that the contract was 'weeks away'. Three MPs and the Nasze Dane group are calling for an independent audit, with a protest planned in Warsaw on 8 Nov. The ABW says the defence ministry never asked it for a security audit, and the German, French and Swiss militaries have previously rejected Palantir publicly. On the UK NHS renewal, Foxglove has revealed that Schedule 8.5 of the contract obliges Palantir to provide up to 24 months of transition support. On Foxglove's reading, the FT's line that the NHS 'cannot replace in 4 months' is therefore wrong. Bloomberg reports that Palantir hired Tom Watson (former Labour deputy leader) in September and that the hire lobbied the health secretary in the weeks before the renewal. The renewal looks like the result of a political timeline and lobbying, not product lock-in. With a domestic alternative also being cultivated, there is a real risk of churn within two years. There were no new commercial customers today. International commercial revenue grew only 1% QoQ in Q3, and international remains the weakest leg of the thesis.

Key evidence

  • Poland Maven timeline: MOU and NDA in Dec 2024, then an LOI in Oct 2025 (customised Maven Smart System Poland). Defence minister Kosiniak-Kamysz said on 6 Nov that negotiations have run for months, led by the Cyber Defence Forces Command, and are awaiting the conclusion of a military analysis
  • Wprost: Palantir representatives told the presidential team in New York in September that the contract was 'weeks away'. The minister now says 'one to two months'
  • Opposition: three MPs (Civic Coalition, Left, Razem) and the Nasze Dane group are demanding an independent audit. A protest in Warsaw is planned for 8 Nov
  • ABW (Internal Security Agency) told TVN24 that the defence ministry never requested a security audit from it
  • Earlier rejections: the German, French and Swiss militaries publicly rejected Palantir
  • No dollar figure disclosed for the Poland deal. An LOI signed more than a year ago has still not become a contract, which fits with Q3 TCV growth of only 6%
Show 6 more
  • Foxglove, 6 Nov, citing Schedule 8.5 of the contract: Palantir must provide up to 24 months of transition support if the contract is not renewed. This contradicts the FT's framing that 4 months is too short to replace it
  • Bloomberg, 6 Nov: Tom Watson (ex-Labour deputy leader) was hired by Palantir in September as a UK executive and lobbied the Health Secretary in the weeks before the renewal
  • The UK renewal, plus a parallel effort to cultivate a domestic alternative, means a real risk of churn within two years
  • Caveats: the lobbying detail comes from a single source (Bloomberg only). The contract terms are the interpretation of an activist group (Foxglove), and the original contract has not been seen
  • SEC EDGAR: no new Form 4 since 4 Nov (the Friedman board transaction was already reported yesterday)
  • NATO HQ already uses Maven (procured in Mar 2025). If Poland signs, the path of NATO HQ using it and member states then deploying it is validated

Catalysts to watch

  • Signing of the Poland Maven contract (timing uncertain: the minister says one to two months, but the LOI is more than a year old)
  • Anti-Palantir protest in Warsaw on 8 Nov
  • Decision by the Polish defence ministry on an independent audit
  • Progress on the UK domestic NHS alternative RFP
  • Further news on European sovereign deals

Risks

  • European political friction is showing up as contracting delays, and both Poland and the UK fit the pattern
  • Germany, France and Switzerland have already rejected Palantir publicly, so acceptance across the EU cannot be taken for granted
  • International commercial growth of only 1% QoQ confirms that international is the weakest leg
  • The UK renewal owes more to lobbying and a political timeline than to product lock-in, which reframes the Q3 narrative
  • Q3 TCV growth of 6% fits with slow conversion from LOI to contract in government
Show 2 more
  • Calls for an independent audit in Poland could set a template for other EU markets
  • The Tom Watson lobbying angle risks reputational damage if it is widely reported

Sources 7

  1. RMF24 (6 Nov)
  2. Gazeta.pl (6 Nov)
  3. Wprost (5 Nov)
  4. TVN24 (ABW statement)
  5. Foxglove (6 Nov, citing contract Schedule 8.5)
  6. Bloomberg (6 Nov, Tom Watson lobbying)
  7. SEC EDGAR (Form 4 check)