Stray Dog

Meta Muse: small Ember model gives hard cost data

  • Good news: Ember costs $0.14 a task against $0.41 for Haiku 5.5 at the same intelligence, a path to cheaper Muse.
  • Mixed: Ember is not yet in the consumer Muse, and there is no new official data on its costs or users.
  • Bad news: Five big UK banks and large US and Canadian banks are blocking agents, shutting off managing money and paying bills.
Read the full notes

Neutral. For the first time there is hard data on the cost line (Ember costs $0.14 a task against $0.41 for Haiku 5.5 at the same intelligence, and is 17 times cheaper than Muse Spark 1.3). It offers a path to the goal of being 'cheap enough to use in every product', but Ember is not yet in the consumer version of Muse.

Read more

The two things that really decide the thesis, how much the consumer version saves and its daily active users and retention, have no new official data. Five big UK banks and large US and Canadian banks are blocking agents together, so the stickiest personal-assistant use, managing money and paying bills, is being shut off systematically. The figure of 11 million UK users rests on a single source, The Sunday Times, and is not treated as fact for now.

Key evidence

  • Muse Ember was released on 9 Nov. It is the fourth model in the Muse family and the first small model trained with Muse Wonder Full, aimed at repetitive agent steps (calling tools, dispatching tasks, extracting information)
  • Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index of 36, level with Claude Haiku 5.5. Cost per task is $0.14 against $0.41 for Haiku 5.5
  • Muse Spark 1.3 scores 37 but costs $2.39 a task, so Ember has similar intelligence and is about 17 times cheaper
  • Limits: available only through the Meta Model API and Muse Code, not in the consumer Muse or Meta AI. Prices rise threefold beyond 200,000 tokens of context
  • Zuckerberg on the Q3 earnings call: Muse has not been rolled out worldwide because it is 'very compute-hungry', with a goal of improving cost efficiency by more than 10 times next year. The official wording is 'cheap enough for everyone to use in every product'
  • Expedia went live in Muse in the US on 9 Nov (Skift; Expedia CEO Gorin previewed it on the 4 Nov earnings call): users search and book hotels in natural language, and Expedia is the merchant of record
Show 6 more
  • Bookings cannot be cancelled or changed inside Muse; customers must contact Expedia support. This follows the Booking and Airbnb approach: they integrate, but keep their main traffic at home
  • The Daily Telegraph, 8 Nov: five big UK banks block AI agents: HSBC, Nationwide, NatWest, Barclays and Lloyds. Some explicitly ban agents from starting transactions without the customer's direct involvement
  • Add US banks JPMorgan, Schwab, Citi and Bank of America, and Canada's Royal Bank, and big banks are collectively keeping financial accounts out of reach
  • India pricing, revealed by The Hindu on 9 Nov: the premium tier is Rs 1,799 a month and the top tier Rs 8,999 a month, broadly in line with US prices. Meta did not respond
  • The web and WhatsApp versions work in India, but cannot pay by card on the user's behalf (the payment interface is not yet in place). An executive at a large Indian payment gateway denied working with Muse
  • The Apple Watch app launched on 9 Nov (MacRumors): it supports typing, dictation and direct calls, with a watch-face shortcut. The iPad version launched in October

Catalysts to watch

  • When Ember reaches the consumer Muse (whether the unit economics hold up)
  • The first disclosure of consumer Muse cost, daily active users and retention
  • The official UK launch (the 11 million user rumour needs checking)
  • A local payment interface in India
  • The launch of the Muse Charm hardware

Risks

  • Five big UK banks and large US and Canadian banks are blocking agents together, so the stickiest personal-assistant use, managing money and paying bills, is being shut off systematically
  • Connectors such as Expedia can only take orders, not handle after-sales, so Muse remains a 'front desk' in the transaction chain
  • India is priced like the US with no local payments, so paid conversion is in doubt
  • There is no new official data on consumer Muse's unit economics or user numbers
  • Ember's price rises threefold beyond 200,000 tokens of context, which weakens its cost advantage on complex tasks
  • The figure of 11 million UK users rests on a single source, The Sunday Times, and Meta declined to comment

Sources 9

  1. research.meta.ai official blog (9 Nov)
  2. Fello AI
  3. Artificial Analysis leaderboard
  4. Skift (9 Nov)
  5. Expedia Q3 earnings call (4 Nov)
  6. The Daily Telegraph (8 Nov)
  7. The Hindu (9 Nov)
  8. MacRumors (9 Nov)
  9. App Store release notes