Stray Dog

SpaceX: 800 MHz filing accepted, KeyBanc warns on churn

  • Bad news: KeyBanc estimates annualised churn of about 55% and average monthly revenue down 13% year on year.
  • Mixed: The FCC accepted the Grain 800 MHz transfer for filing, not yet approved; rapid-build conditions bring capital spending forward.
  • Bad news: BT is holding off its Starlink launch until the noise over Ukraine dies down.
Read the full notes

Seven threads advance the framework of vertical integration and higher revenue per user, but two risks have escalated. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has formally accepted the application to transfer Grain's 800 MHz spectrum (546 pairs of licences, covering about 100% of the population).

Read more

The accompanying rapid-build conditions mean capital spending comes first, which backs Höttges' 'at least 200 billion'. The Starlink Mini 2 at $999 bundles a year of service, continuing the pattern of dynamic-pricing increases. KeyBanc third-party data warns of annualised churn of about 55% and average monthly revenue down 13% year on year. If that is right, Q4 revenue growth of 70% QoQ is more likely to come from AI compute and non-government new businesses than from broadband subscribers. The Ukraine episode has spilled into commercial channels (BT is holding off its launch). StarMind's complete heterojunction cell line from Germany's Singulus supports the Q3 2027 timetable. And state air-permit risk for the Starbase power plant has risen (Abbott has ordered a halt to data-centre permits).

Brief ID

2026-11-11-spacex-800mhz-mini2-churn-bt-starmind-stargate-permit

Key evidence

  • FCC public notice DA-26-1218 (10 Nov) formally accepts the Grain transfer: 546 pairs of 800 MHz licences, up to 14 MHz, covering all 50 states, Washington DC and Puerto Rico, about 100% of the population
  • The application was filed on 9 Oct. It is accepted for filing and open for public comment, and has not been approved
  • The rapid-build conditions attached to Grain (terrestrial and direct-to-phone) still apply after the transfer to SpaceX
  • On 27 Oct SpaceX applied to amend the Starlink Mobile satellite authorisation so that 800 MHz can also be used for supplementary satellite coverage
  • Bloomberg: a California public-employee pension fund has bet on this spectrum and has roughly doubled its money in about a year (the price paid was not disclosed)
  • Starlink Mini 2 (official X account and PCMag, 10 Nov): 71 Wh removable battery, 4.5 hours of runtime, Wi-Fi 6, 60 W USB-C power
Show 20 more
  • The Mini 2 is available only to invited US users, at $999 including 12 months of Roam Unlimited ($100 upfront and $899 on shipping), with shipping expected in mid-December
  • The earlier website leak of $249 plus $50 for the battery has not been confirmed officially
  • KeyBanc app data estimates (Broadband Breakfast, 10 Nov): about 1.16 million app downloads in October (+55% year on year), and about 389,000 in the US, a record
  • Monthly active users were roughly flat QoQ: US -5%, overseas +4%
  • Estimated annualised churn is about 55% (over 4% a month), against 1-2% a month for traditional broadband
  • Estimated average monthly revenue is about $113, down 13% year on year, and Q4 net additions are estimated at about 2.4 million (1.6 million in Q3)
  • Musk's figure for Q4 revenue growth is 70% QoQ
  • BT (FT and Reuters, 10 Nov): CEO Kirkby says the satellite broadband technology is ready (originally planned for H2 2026) but will not be pushed until the noise over Ukraine dies down
  • EU defence commissioner Kubilius: Starlink will lose trust if it breaches paid contracts with European countries
  • From 2027 Ukraine can access EU GOVSATCOM
  • StarMind supply chain: Germany's Singulus (announcement, 10 Nov) is supplying a complete heterojunction solar cell line, a turnkey line to be installed at the Bastrop Gigasat, with the first delivery in H1 2027
  • Singulus has annual revenue of only about €48 million, so this is a single order of material size. The value is not verified in a primary announcement
  • Starbase power plant (Politico, 10 Nov): SpaceX has applied to the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality for an air permit for 35 mobile gas turbines, about 750 MW
  • Texas Tribune: Governor Abbott has ordered the commission to halt data-centre permits
  • Starship Flight 15: booster B22 went to Pad 2 on 10 Nov for pressure testing. The target is still 13 Nov, pending Federal Aviation Administration approval
  • KeepTrack counted 11,190 working Starlink satellites on 10 Nov, against about 396 for Amazon Leo (none added since early July)
  • Private aviation firm Slate Aviation is switching its entire fleet from Gogo to Starlink, with installation starting next month
  • Taiwan's draft 2027 budget proposes buying Amazon Leo for emergency backup communications, and Singapore's Can Marine has become a Leo maritime reseller
  • A US appeals court rejected SpaceX's arbitration request, so a gender-discrimination suit by eight engineers must be formally defended (Reuters, 10 Nov)
  • SEC EDGAR: no new filings since the 8-K of 6 Nov

Reporter

Our research team

Catalysts to watch

  • The end of the FCC public comment period on the 800 MHz transfer, and the final approval decision
  • Approval of the amendment to the Starlink Mobile satellite authorisation for supplementary 800 MHz coverage
  • Official subscriber numbers in the 10-K (to test KeyBanc's churn estimate)
  • A breakdown of the 70% QoQ Q4 revenue growth (broadband versus AI compute versus non-government new businesses)
  • Mini 2 shipping progress and activation data in mid-December
Show 8 more
  • BT's decision to go ahead with or delay the Starlink launch
  • Budgets and timetables for European sovereign alternatives (IRIS², GOVSATCOM)
  • Delivery of the Singulus line to the Bastrop Gigasat in H1 2027
  • The Texas Commission on Environmental Quality's ruling on the 35-turbine air permit
  • Where the new governor Hinojosa's pause on Starbase land disposal ends up
  • The 9 Dec Starbase city tax abatement (a formality)
  • FAA approval for Starship Flight 15 and the 13 Nov window
  • Progress in the engineers' gender-discrimination suit

Risks

  • If KeyBanc's 55% churn is right, dynamic-pricing increases push churn higher still
  • Average monthly revenue down 13% year on year points to pressure on revenue per user
  • Trust in European commercial channels is damaged (BT holding off, Kubilius's public warning)
  • The political drive for sovereign alternatives in the EU (GOVSATCOM and IRIS²) is strengthening
  • The 800 MHz rapid-build conditions force capital spending forward (backing the 200 billion requirement)
Show 3 more
  • Abbott's halt on data-centre permits, together with the pause on land disposal during the governor handover, means the Starbase power plant is held up at state level, not city level
  • The arbitration shield in the engineers' gender-discrimination suit has been rejected, increasing legal exposure
  • Amazon Leo is stalled in satellites but expanding in channels (Taiwan, Singapore)

Sources 10

  1. FCC public notice DA-26-1218 (10 Nov)
  2. Starlink official X account / PCMag (10 Nov)
  3. Broadband Breakfast (10 Nov, KeyBanc estimates)
  4. Financial Times / Reuters (10 Nov)
  5. Singulus announcement / MarketScreener / Reuters (10 Nov)
  6. Politico (10 Nov)
  7. Texas Tribune
  8. KeepTrack (10 Nov)
  9. Bloomberg
  10. SEC EDGAR