Meta Muse: merchants report tiny agent orders, United widens block
- Bad news: Wired spoke to about 50 companies: DoorDash sees 'a few hundred orders' and Life Time 'zero', which undercuts Meta's shopping claim.
- Bad news: United now also restricts indirect access via travel agencies and price-comparison sites, narrowing what Muse can book for users.
- Mixed: ByteDance will release a Muse-style agent within weeks: it endorses Muse's product, but brings a rival and price-war risk.
Read the full notes
Three threads point to the same conclusion: Muse's distribution advantage is not in doubt, but its ability to actually get things done on users' behalf was weakened again this week. (1) Wired spoke to about 50 companies.
Read more
DoorDash said 'a few hundred orders', Hilton 'not significant', T-Mobile 'not seeing meaningful volume', Ally 'pretty low', eBay 'very, very small' and Life Time 'zero'. The only positive was Chipotle, with growth in the single-digit percentages, and it is changing its website to suit agents. Meta's claim that 'more than a quarter of users use it for shopping' does not square with the merchants' data. (2) United is not just blocking direct access but also using changes to its booking, ticketing and distribution policies to shut off indirect access through travel agencies and price-comparison platforms (Muse's flight booking runs partly through Duffel's interface). The airline block list is growing (Delta and Amtrak before it), while Expedia and Booking have chosen to work with OpenAI. (3) ByteDance will release a personal agent modelled on Muse within weeks. Becoming the industry reference suggests Muse leads on product definition, but ByteDance serves users in China and overseas TikTok users, so its overlap with Muse's current markets (the US, Canada, Japan, Singapore and Mexico) is limited in the short term.
Key evidence
- Wired, 11 Nov: a roundup of about 50 companies' earnings calls and interviews
- DoorDash: orders from agents such as Muse are only 'a few hundred'
- Hilton: agent hotel bookings are 'not significant'
- T-Mobile: 'not seeing any meaningful volume'
- Ally Bank: 'pretty low'
- eBay: 'very, very small'
Show 13 more
- Life Time: membership cancellations through agents are 'zero'
- Chipotle's head of digital: agent orders have grown by a single-digit percentage since Muse launched; agents often get stuck on member discounts and orders placed outside opening hours; it is changing its website code to suit agents
- Meta declined to add data beyond the earnings call, pointing only to its work with 10 retailers including Walmart, Best Buy and Gap
- For comparison: agents account for only about 500 food-delivery orders out of Uber's 320 million; Airbnb calls agents 'very insignificant'
- Meta's claim that 'more than a quarter of users use it for shopping' does not square with the volume merchants are seeing
- United, 11 Nov (Reuters/CNBC): it is restricting AI bots from its website and app, citing data security. Handing account passwords to a third-party assistant could lead to mistaken purchases, altered accounts and misused miles, and agents that check in automatically bypass the manual confirmation of prohibited items
- United's key point: it will not only block direct access but also restrict indirect access through travel agencies and price-comparison platforms by changing its booking, ticketing and distribution policies
- Muse's flight booking runs partly through flight-booking interfaces such as Duffel (according to reports)
- The airline block list has grown: United has joined Delta and Amtrak
- Expedia and Booking have chosen to work with OpenAI, so Muse is not well placed in travel
- Bloomberg, 11 Nov (reproduced by the Economic Times): ByteDance did not respond; Zhang Yiming told an internal all-hands meeting that an AI assistant positioned like Muse will be released within weeks
- Zhang Yiming admitted that ByteDance will not catch up with the top US labs on frontier models until 2029-2030
- ByteDance's products mainly serve users in China and overseas TikTok users; Muse's current markets are the US, Canada, Japan, Singapore and Mexico
Catalysts to watch
- Whether Meta's next earnings report discloses Muse's actual GMV or merchant-side transaction volume (it currently gives only user-usage figures)
- Whether Chipotle's volume can jump from single-digit to double-digit percentage growth once its website is adapted for agents
- Whether more airlines follow United in blocking indirect channels
- The launch and feature definition of ByteDance's Muse rival within weeks
- The actual share of travel taken by the OpenAI partnerships with Expedia and Booking
- Whether interfaces such as Duffel stay open to Muse under United's new policy
Risks
- Evidence of short-term monetisation has been missing for two weeks running, and merchant-side data discount the value of Muse's ability to get things done
- The airline block has widened from direct access to distribution channels, materially narrowing what Muse can do on users' behalf
- Meta has declined to add data, so the gap between the CEO's figures and the merchants' cannot be verified
- OpenAI is ahead in travel, and Muse has not won a partnership with a leading online travel agency
- ByteDance has passively admitted that it trails on frontier models until 2029-2030: a rival that follows Muse is both an endorsement and a warning of a price war
- One company, Chipotle, adapting voluntarily is not a large-scale trend, and most merchants are still waiting or blocking
Sources 7
- Wired, 11 Nov
- Reuters, 11 Nov
- CNBC, 11 Nov
- Bloomberg, 11 Nov
- Economic Times (reproducing the report on ByteDance following Muse)
- Meta earnings call, public disclosures
- Reports on Duffel's flight-booking interface