Stray Dog

NHS England pulls Palantir trust list; MoD deal overdue

  • Bad news: NHS England removed its list of 137 trusts using the data platform, and the Statistics Regulator is reviewing its usage claims.
  • Bad news: The MoD's £240 million no-bid deal is more than 6 months overdue for publication of its contract text.
  • Mixed: Renewal is still with the minister, expected before Christmas. The NHS deal is about £330 million over 7 years, a small run rate.
Read the full notes

Two PLTR items on the UK public sector on 13 Nov. (1) NHS England quietly removed its list of 137 trusts benefiting from the Federated Data Platform (Guardian, 12 Nov). The Guardian had earlier revealed that 29 of those trusts said they had not gone live or were barely using it. The page now carries vague copy saying early adopters are seeing benefits.

Read more

The UK Statistics Regulator is reviewing the usage claims and has already flagged the claim of an extra 117,000 operations as unsupported. Opposition is widening. Unison demands termination, and Medact, the BMA and Amnesty UK have co-signed a letter to the Prime Minister and the Health Secretary. The letter cites the contract's termination assistance period as a safe exit in 2027 and opposes a two-year transition to a UK domestic alternative. This confirms our earlier read that the renewal is a question of political timing and lobbying rather than product lock-in: with the official usage framing walked back, FDP penetration in the NHS is shallower than marketed and the product case for renewal weakens. The counterpoint is that the renewal is still with the minister, who is expected to decide before Christmas. The contract is worth about £330 million over 7 years, a small annual run rate. The real risks are a replacement by a UK domestic solution in 2029 and damage to the narrative of the UK public sector as a flagship template. (2) Democracy for Sale reported on 12 Nov that the MoD's £240 million no-bid enterprise agreement, signed in Dec 2025, should have had its contract text or a confidentiality rationale published within 90 days under the 2023 Procurement Act. The MoD only posted a notice saying a redacted version is available on request, a mechanism the law does not provide for. Disclosure is now more than 6 months overdue. The MoD calls it an administrative error and says publication is coming soon. Add the earlier FT report that the MoD actually paid about £186 million more over ten years than published contracts show, and Palantir's role in leading a review of procurement rules, and the UK defence question is shifting from whether it should get the work to whether the process was compliant. Two parliamentary committees have already demanded that the NHS contract's break clause be exercised, and defence-side transparency challenges arm the opposition further. The counterpoint is that this is a procedural flaw only, with no sign of cancellation or re-tender. The MoD's dependence on Palantir is deep, so the near-term revenue impact is limited.

Key evidence

  • Guardian, 12 Nov: NHS England removed the list of 137 trusts benefiting from the Federated Data Platform from its website
  • Replacement page: vague copy saying early users are seeing benefits, with no trust names
  • Earlier Guardian reporting: 29 of the 137 trusts said they had not gone live or were barely using FDP
  • UK Office for Statistics Regulation is reviewing NHS England's usage claims and has already said the claim of an extra 117,000 operations is unsupported
  • Trade union Unison demands termination of the contract
  • Joint letter from Medact, the BMA and Amnesty UK to the Prime Minister and Health Secretary: use the termination assistance period to exit safely in 2027 and reject a two-year transition to a UK domestic solution
Show 9 more
  • NHS FDP contract: about £330 million over 7 years (a small annual run rate)
  • Renewal decision still with the minister; expected before Christmas
  • Democracy for Sale, 12 Nov: MoD £240 million no-bid enterprise agreement signed in Dec 2025
  • The 2023 Procurement Act requires the contract text or a confidentiality rationale to be published within 90 days
  • The MoD posted only a notice that a redacted version is available on request, which the 2023 Act does not provide for
  • More than 6 months overdue; the MoD calls it an administrative error and promises publication soon
  • Earlier FT report: the MoD actually paid about £186 million more over ten years than published contracts show
  • Palantir is taking part in a UK review of procurement rules from which it benefits
  • Two parliamentary committees have already demanded that the NHS contract's break clause be exercised

Catalysts to watch

  • Minister's decision on the NHS FDP renewal, expected before Christmas
  • Formal findings from the UK Statistics Regulator on NHS usage claims
  • The MoD actually publishing the £240 million contract text
  • Whether the NHS break clause is exercised
  • Activation of the termination assistance period in 2027
Show 2 more
  • Possible replacement by a UK domestic alternative in 2029
  • Further parliamentary committee action

Risks

  • The renewal case weakens: the NHS itself is walking back the evidence of product use
  • Two parliamentary committees are already pushing for the break clause, so this is not just lobbying noise
  • The UK public sector is a flagship narrative and is at risk if the NHS exits or a UK domestic solution replaces Palantir in 2029
  • Defence procurement questions are shifting from merit to compliance, which is harder to defend politically
  • The opposition now has both the NHS and the MoD as procedural targets
Show 3 more
  • Counterpoint: the £330 million, 7-year NHS deal is small relative to Palantir's total business, so the direct revenue impact is modest
  • The MoD's dependence is deep, so a procedural scandal is unlikely to force cancellation in the short term
  • The minister could still renew despite the official retraction of the usage claims

Sources 7

  1. Guardian, 12 Nov (NHS England removes list of 137 trusts using FDP)
  2. Democracy for Sale, 12 Nov (MoD £240 million Palantir contract overdue for disclosure)
  3. Unison trade union statement
  4. Joint letter from Medact, the BMA and Amnesty UK to the Prime Minister and Health Secretary
  5. UK Office for Statistics Regulation earlier findings
  6. FT earlier report on the MoD's £186 million overpayment against published contracts
  7. 2023 Procurement Act (statutory 90-day publication requirement)