Tesla picks Berlin for Cybercab as NHTSA crash count hits record
- Mixed: Tesla's second Berlin factory will build the Cybercab: €3 billion, production from 2029. But EU small-series approval is capped at 1,500 vehicles per model per year.
- Bad news: NHTSA data show 264 Tesla driver-assistance crashes in September, a record, including 3 fatal crashes with Verified Engaged status.
- Mixed: Musk hinted a pilot adding owners' cars to the network could start as early as December, but it was only an X reply.
Read the full notes
Tesla has named its second Berlin factory as the Cybercab production site: €3 billion, production from 2029, designed capacity of 1 million vehicles a year. It is the heaviest capital commitment yet, but EU regulation has not caught up (small-series approval is capped at 1,500 vehicles per model per year).
Read more
In Texas, only 573 Cybercabs have been registered seven months after production began, so the bottleneck is deployment, not capacity. Musk hinted that a pilot letting owners add their cars to the network could start as early as December, well ahead of the 2027 Q2 timeline Ashok gave on the Q3 call. The Miami Robotaxi service area has grown 92%. NHTSA data show 264 Tesla driver-assistance crashes in September, a record, including 3 fatal crashes with Verified Engaged status. Cybercab has had 8 crashes in total, but the median Robotaxi speed was 1 mph. In Texas, Waymo (1,321 authorised vehicles) has moved back ahead of Tesla (1,306).
Key evidence
- Berlin plant manager Thierig announced on X on 16 Nov, and Tesla issued a statement the same day (Electrek, electrive): the new buildings are a €3 billion first phase with designed capacity of 1 million vehicles a year. A construction application is due by year end, work starts in the first half of 2027 and production in 2029
- An older report from 13 Nov said the second factory would not build the Model Y and had no set purpose. By 17 Nov it had been designated for Cybercab
- EU rules: driverless models are approved as small series, with a cap of 1,500 vehicles per model per year across Europe. Tesla holds no unsupervised driving permit anywhere in Europe (only the supervised Tesla Assisted Driving)
- Cybercab production began at the Texas plant in April. By 17 Nov registrations had stalled at 573
- Musk replied on X on 16 Nov to an Austin ride-hailing driver: the pilot for adding owners' vehicles to the network could start as early as December. On the Q3 call Ashok gave around 2027 Q2
- A standard Model Y lacks the extra communications module and camera-cleaning hardware of the Robotaxi fleet version. Under the purchase agreement, a Cybercab bought by an individual cannot join the network
Show 8 more
- Miami: according to the official new map of 16 Nov, Robotaxi Tracker estimates the service area grew from about 31 square miles to 59 square miles (+92%), adding downtown and Brickell
- Austin: 272 to 443 square miles (+63%). Houston: 25 to 254 square miles
- The latest NHTSA Standing General Order release covers reports through 15 Oct (compiled by Electrek). Tesla's 264 driver-assistance crashes in September were a monthly record (236 in July, 135 in March)
- All 3 new fatal crashes were Verified Engaged: a Model Y at 71 mph into an overturned lorry on I-75 in Naples, Florida (3 dead); a Model Y hitting a tree and catching fire in El Dorado Hills, California (3 dead); and a Model X hitting a signal pole in Naples (1 dead). Tesla redacted the crash narratives as trade secrets
- Cybercab has had 8 crashes in total: 4 during driverless Robotaxi operations (speeds of 5 mph or less, the other party at fault in 2) and 4 in test vehicles with safety drivers, including a 53 mph crash on a Philadelphia highway (Tesla has no autonomous driving permit in Pennsylvania)
- All 43 Robotaxi reports: top speed 29 mph, median speed 1 mph, no high-speed crashes
- Active FSD subscriptions are up 67% year on year (NHTSA publishes no crash rate per mile)
- Texas DMV list of 16 Nov (GoodCarBadCar): Tesla 1,306, Waymo 1,321. On 12 Nov we reported Tesla at 1,302 ahead of Waymo at 1,297, and Tesla has since been overtaken (Tesla +4, Waymo +24 in the period)
Catalysts to watch
- Construction starts on the Berlin Cybercab factory in the first half of 2027
- Berlin Cybercab production starts in 2029
- Whether the EU opens up high-volume driverless approvals before 2029
- Whether the December pilot for adding owners' vehicles to the network gets under way (if delivered, well ahead of Ashok's 2027 Q2)
- Safety record of owner vehicles on the network, and the number of remote operators per vehicle
Show 2 more
- First proof of unsupervised highway driving (a key gate for owner vehicles joining the network and for Cybercab sales across the US)
- Weekly updates to the Texas authorised vehicle count (Tesla and Waymo increments compared)
Risks
- If the EU does not open up high-volume approvals, Berlin's 1 million vehicle capacity will have nowhere to go when production starts in 2029
- Tesla has no unsupervised driving permit anywhere in Europe, and Texas Cybercab registrations have stalled at 573 over seven months, which shows the bottleneck is deployment, not capacity
- Musk's December timing for owner vehicles joining the network is only an X reply, with no vehicle model, owner eligibility or revenue split, and the standard Model Y lacks the hardware
- Three new fatal NHTSA crashes were Verified Engaged and Tesla redacted the reports, so regulatory and litigation pressure is rising
- Unsupervised highway driving has not been proven at all, yet both owner vehicles joining the network and Cybercab sales across the US depend on it
Show 2 more
- Tesla's stalled increment in Texas authorised vehicles (+4 against Waymo's +24) and the 573 Cybercab registrations are the same signal: the bottleneck is deployment
- Fleet and mileage growth explain part of the rise in absolute FSD crashes (active subscriptions +67%), but NHTSA has no crash rate per mile, so the system's quality cannot be judged directly
Sources 12
- Thierig X post 16 Nov 2026
- Tesla official statement 16 Nov 2026
- Electrek Berlin Cybercab coverage 16 Nov 2026
- electrive Berlin Cybercab coverage 16 Nov 2026
- Elon Musk X reply 16 Nov 2026 (Robotaxi owner vehicle pilot)
- Tesla Q3 2026 earnings call (Ashok on 2027 Q2 timeline)
- @robotaxi X Miami map 16 Nov 2026
- Robotaxi Tracker Miami service area calculation
- NHTSA Standing General Order release through 15 Oct 2026
- Electrek NHTSA crash data analysis
- Texas DMV AV authorized vehicles list 16 Nov 2026
- GoodCarBadCar TX DMV compilation