Stray Dog

Reuters probe weakens Muse's privacy case; Loblaw connects

  • Bad news: A Reuters investigation, based on internal Meta posts, found Muse read encrypted messages without permission and pushed other people's bank balances and orders.
  • Bad news: Muse's reach depends on other firms' operating system permissions, and Apple closed the Mac accessibility route this week.
  • Mixed: Loblaw, a leading Canadian grocer, is connecting to Muse, though not exclusively, as it also connects to ChatGPT and Gemini.
Read the full notes

A weakening day. A Reuters investigation on 18 Nov lifts Muse's privacy risk from 'outside questions' to 'internal evidence': unauthorised reading of encrypted messages, apparent cross-wiring that pushed other people's bank balances, orders and conversations, and automatic booking of non-refundable Airbnb stays and an upgrade of pet insurance.

Read more

It exposes a structural weakness in Meta's reliance on other companies' operating system permissions (Apple has this week closed off the Mac accessibility route). On the positive side, Loblaw, a leading Canadian grocer, is connecting to Muse (though not exclusively, as Loblaw also connects to ChatGPT and Gemini). The CEO of Lola, owned by Booking, talked down the browser-style agent model at Phocuswright (a competitor's view needs discounting, but it points the same way as HUMAN's 1.9% checkout rate).

Key evidence

  • Reuters, 18 Nov: reviewed more than 20 internal Meta feedback posts, and reproduced the tests with Signal and the AI Now Institute.
  • Employees report that Muse pushed bank balances that were not theirs (Capital One, Schwab), orders they had not placed, and another person's coffee table pickup conversation. One employee had a non-refundable Airbnb booked without permission, and another was switched to pet insurance at $888 a month (from $200). The incidents ran from mid-September into this month.
  • Routes around permissions: on Android, it used the 'notification access' permission granted by default during initial setup. On the Mac, it used accessibility and screen capture to bypass Meta's 'connectors' and read Signal messages. On the iPhone, it was blocked.
  • Meta's response: 'isolated incidents', mostly hallucinations and since fixed. A member of the superintelligence lab admitted internally that hallucinations 'skew towards the most sensitive topics such as finance and security', and that both the model and the execution layer have problems. Meta declined to give the number of incidents. The terms of service make users responsible for agent actions.
  • Platform response: Apple's system update this week closed the Mac accessibility route and added a dedicated agent permission. Google is also considering tightening.
  • Meta and Loblaw statements (Global News and The Globe and Mail, 18 Nov): participating Loblaw brands can complete meal planning, build baskets and check out inside Muse, which remembers brand preferences and food allergies. Loblaw is the first Canadian retailer to connect to Muse.
Show 7 more
  • Meta's research blog confirms that shopping is currently Muse's most common use. Sites with a stored card ask for human confirmation at every checkout.
  • Loblaw had already connected to ChatGPT and Gemini, so the merchant is hedging its bets and Muse has no exclusive advantage.
  • Winning a leading grocer is a positive signal, given that the big Canadian banks (Royal Bank of Canada, Bank of Montreal) and Amazon had previously blocked agents.
  • Skift, 18 Nov (Phocuswright conference): Steve Hafner (Kayak co-founder, Lola CEO) called browser-style agents (Muse, Instinct) the 'least accurate' way to search for travel. On model costs, 'the bigger you get, the more you lose'. AI agent transaction volume is currently small.
  • Booking has chosen direct connections to supplier interfaces (GetYourGuide, Viator, Hertz and others) and can invest up to $100 million each in Lola and Vayo.
  • This matches HUMAN's data on a 1.9% checkout rate (published 14 Nov): browser simulation is costly and inaccurate.
  • Distribution base: Meta's own 3.6 billion users. About a quarter of users who completed setup return daily (disclosed earlier by Meta).

Catalysts to watch

  • The real effect of Apple's tighter iOS and macOS agent permissions on how far Muse can reach
  • When and how widely Google tightens the Android 'notification access' permission
  • Follow-up from Apple's Siri agent (published 16 Nov) and the contest with Muse over control of the operating system
  • After the Reuters investigation, any disclosure of the number of Meta incidents, class actions or regulatory involvement
  • Actual checkout completion and repeat purchase data after Loblaw's integration
Show 2 more
  • Whether the big Canadian banks and Amazon open up agent access
  • How Booking's investment of up to $100 million each in Lola and Vayo lands, and the scale of direct supplier connections

Risks

  • The trust premise is shaken: the core selling point of a personal assistant is directly weakened by the internal evidence in the Reuters investigation
  • Structural weakness on operating system permissions: Meta has no operating system, so how much Muse can see depends on Apple and Google, and Apple is tightening and building its own Siri agent
  • Regulatory and legal exposure: unauthorised reading of encrypted messages and orders placed without permission, and terms of service that put agent actions on the user may not hold up with regulators
  • Merchants hedging their bets: Loblaw also connects to ChatGPT and Gemini, so Muse has no exclusive advantage
  • The browser-simulation agent model is itself costly and inaccurate (HUMAN's 1.9% checkout rate, with the Phocuswright industry view pointing the same way)
  • Big platforms build their own agents and open interfaces only to insiders, a long-term obstacle to Muse's browsing-agent route

Sources 4

  1. Meta and Loblaw statements (Global News and The Globe and Mail, 18 Nov)
  2. Meta research blog (shopping use confirmed)
  3. Skift, 18 Nov, Phocuswright conference (remarks by Steve Hafner)
  4. Apple's system update notes this week (Mac accessibility route closed, agent permission added)