Stray Dog

Starbase data centre wins air permit but loses tax abatement

  • Mixed: Starbase's $24 billion data centre won an air emissions permit, but county commissioners voted 3:2 against a property tax abatement.
  • Good news: ST3 Insights estimates about 120,000 US customers switched to Starlink in Q3, four gained for every one lost, taking share from cable.
  • Bad news: A price rise on the aviation plan led about 1,000 US owners to cancel, according to a class action.
Read the full notes

Seven updates. The $24 billion Starbase data centre has won an air emissions permit, but Cameron County commissioners voted 3:2 against a 10-year, 100% property tax abatement (self-built power works, but the economics are discounted).

Read more

ST3 Insights estimates that about 120,000 US customers switched to Starlink from other broadband providers in Q3, four gained for every one lost, taking share from cable and fixed wireless. A price rise on the aviation plan led about 1,000 US owners to cancel (disclosed in a class action). Direct-to-cell reaches a new market, Mongolia (partnership with Mobicom under the mobispace brand). Transportation Secretary Duffy said publicly on 17 Nov that the FAA turned down free Starlink terminals (confirming Musk's one-sided account of the refusal). Amazon says its Leo target of starting service by year end is unchanged, after losing 40 satellites in the Vulcan failure. SpaceXAI subsidiary bought 96 acres in Memphis for $5.5 million, and Ukrainian forces deliberately avoided Starshield in a bridge strike.

Key evidence

  • On 16 Nov the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality issued an air emissions permit for the $24 billion Starbase data centre: 35 gas turbines, 750 megawatts, and a nitrogen oxide cap of 248 tonnes a year (Politico saw the original permit). Review of the data centre permit that Abbott halted in September has resumed.
  • The same week, Cameron County commissioners voted 3:2 against continuing talks on a 10-year, 100% property tax abatement. A commissioner who voted in favour said 'this application is dead' (KRGV, Brownsville Herald, Newsweek). Governor-elect Hinojosa has called for a pause on data centre approvals.
  • ST3 Insights (PCMag, 18 Nov): about 120,000 US customers switched to Starlink from other broadband providers in Q3, including more than 27,000 from Spectrum, 17,000 from Xfinity and about 41,000 from AT&T, T-Mobile and Verizon fixed wireless. Starlink was the fastest-growing US broadband provider in Q3.
  • Methodology: consented app data plus IP-based network tracking. This is a third-party estimate, not official data. It is consistent with Ookla's 12 Nov finding that nine in ten new customers came from non-fibre connections and that growth was faster in cities, so Starlink is taking customers from cable and fixed wireless, not just serving rural markets.
  • PCMag, 18 Nov: about 1,000 US owners cancelled (the figure comes from the class action). In September a California customer, Thomas Daniel, sued Starlink for 'bait and switch', saying he was forced from March onto a more expensive aviation plan. The Roam plan gained a 100 mph speed cap. Compare KeyBanc's 11 Nov estimate of a 13% year-on-year fall in monthly revenue per user.
  • @Starlink confirmed on 18 Nov a partnership with Mobicom, Mongolia's largest operator (brand name mobispace). Compatible phones work once data roaming is switched on. Texts and messaging apps come first, with voice and data later. Service is free for the first month for those who sign up before 1 Dec, with pricing afterwards not announced.
Show 5 more
  • Transportation Secretary Duffy admitted at a 17 Nov briefing that the FAA turned down free Starlink terminals, and defended the decision. He said the agency already uses Starlink in some areas and that Starlink is 'part of the solution' rather than a replacement. Musk kept criticising the decision on X on 18 Nov. The agency's new communications system contract is still with Verizon, so Starlink will not win a large contract soon.
  • Fierce, 18 Nov: after losing 40 satellites in the Vulcan failure, Amazon said the first flight was always risky and its target of starting Leo service by year end is unchanged. The Federal Communications Commission set a final deployment deadline of 30 Jul 2029 for the first-generation 3,232 satellites. The date of Vulcan's return to flight is not set, and Leo has about 390 satellites in orbit.
  • WSMV and Memphis Business Journal: SpaceXAI subsidiary CTC Property bought about 96 acres in Whitehaven, Memphis, for $5.5 million (former film studio land, recorded on 16 Nov). The intended use has not been disclosed.
  • Financial Times (UK): Ukrainian forces deliberately avoided Starshield in a bridge strike, using relay drones to get around speed limits, which suggests military customers are looking for alternatives.
  • SEC EDGAR: no new filings since the 13G/A of 16 Nov.

Catalysts to watch

  • Renegotiation of the Starbase data centre economics (the pace of the build after losing the 10-year, 100% property tax abatement)
  • Whether Governor-elect Hinojosa's call to pause data centre approvals is carried out
  • Official pricing for Mongolia's mobispace direct-to-cell service, and when voice and data go live
  • Later tenders for the FAA's new communications system (opportunities beyond the Verizon contract)
  • When Vulcan returns to flight for Amazon Leo, and whether the year-end service commitment is met
Show 3 more
  • Whether Starlink's full-year US net customer additions keep Q3's four-to-one replacement ratio
  • Progress of the aviation plan lawsuit, and follow-up checks on KeyBanc's 13% fall in monthly revenue per user
  • Disclosure of the intended use of the 96 acres in Memphis for SpaceXAI

Risks

  • Starbase data centre economics are discounted: the 10-year, 100% property tax abatement is lost and the governor-elect may pause data centre approvals
  • A sign of losing military customers: Ukrainian forces deliberately avoided Starshield and used relay drones
  • The FAA's refusal of free terminals is confirmed, so government contracts will be hard to win in the short term, and the Transportation Secretary's public stance limits future bargaining room
  • The 'bait and switch' allegation over the aviation plan is still in court. The price rise led about 1,000 owners to cancel, and the 13% fall in monthly revenue per user is an estimate yet to be verified
  • Regulatory and political risks stack up: the local tax abatement was voted down, and there is the governor-elect's stance
  • Competition: Amazon is sticking to a year-end Leo start, and if it delivers, direct competition begins

Sources 9

  1. Politico, 16 Nov, original Texas Commission on Environmental Quality air emissions permit
  2. KRGV, Brownsville Herald, Newsweek: Cameron County commissioners' 3:2 vote against the property tax abatement
  3. PCMag, 18 Nov (citing ST3 Insights and the aviation lawsuit)
  4. @Starlink, 18 Nov, Mongolia partnership announcement
  5. Transportation Secretary Duffy, 17 Nov briefing
  6. Fierce, 18 Nov, Amazon Leo
  7. WSMV and Memphis Business Journal, 16 Nov, CTC Property land registration
  8. Financial Times (UK), report on Ukrainian forces and Starshield alternatives
  9. SEC EDGAR