NHS has not ruled out Palantir, but it gives up lock-in
- Mixed: The UK health secretary has not ruled Palantir out of the new data platform bidding, but Palantir promised in writing to help any migration.
- Bad news: After the Minab school strike, Maven's role in the strike process has deepened and its political risk has risen.
- Bad news: Europe's sovereign alternatives gain another entrant, Sweden's Nordan AI.
Read the full notes
The UK's NHS has not ruled out Palantir after 2029, but Palantir has promised in writing to help with any migration, giving up its lock-in leverage. After the Maven strike on the Minab school, the platform's role in the strike process has deepened and political risk has risen. Europe's sovereign alternatives gain another entrant, Sweden's Nordan AI.
Key evidence
- UK health secretary Frith told the House of Commons on 17 Nov that procurement for the new federated data platform, starting in H2 2027, is open to UK and international suppliers, and that Palantir has not been ruled out of the bidding (Computer Weekly, 20 Nov).
- Palantir wrote to Frith and health minister Cooper promising more exit preparation over the next two years. It says publicly that there is no lock-in, and that the data and intellectual property belong to the NHS.
- Science and Technology Committee chair Onwurah rebutted: a break clause that cannot be used because healthcare continuity must be protected is not a break clause but lock-in. The government has still not published an independent assessment of technology dependence.
- The NHS contract is under 1% of revenue. The real risk is the spread of precedents of European governments choosing to replace Palantir.
- After the February strike on the Minab school, US Central Command changed its target confirmation process and upgraded Maven, adding a feature that flags inconsistent intelligence (Stars and Stripes, 19 Nov, citing Bloomberg).
- Palantir told Bloomberg that the company is not responsible for flaws in the underlying data and intelligence.
Show 5 more
- Third-party testing by Vals: frontier models from 8 companies all treated civilians, ambulances and surrendering soldiers as military targets. Anthropic's Claude performed worst, marking the Iranian school as a target in 22 of 32 tests (Bloomberg, 17 Nov).
- Sankar has previously said Maven has switched to models from xAI, OpenAI, Google and others, and that missions were not affected.
- Sweden's Nordan AI was co-founded by Evelina Anttila, a former investor on the TV show Dragons' Den. It aims to be Sweden's Palantir, and its team includes Spotify core programmer Ludvig Strigeus and engineers from the Swedish Armed Forces (Expressen, 19 Nov).
- Nordan AI's products focus on multi-source data fusion and decision support, with the Swedish Armed Forces among its target customers. It declined to say whether it has won a contract.
- On 20 Nov an insider filed a new Form 144, and the matching Form 4 has not yet appeared.
Catalysts to watch
- Procurement for the NHS's new federated data platform starts in H2 2027
- NHS contract renewal decision in 2029
- After the midterms, Democrats are in the stronger position and Congress may tighten accountability reviews of Maven
- Spread of the European sovereign-alternative trend (home-grown consortia in Germany, France, the Netherlands and the UK)
- Form 4 disclosure of insider selling still to come
Risks
- Palantir has given up its strongest renewal card, the high cost of switching supplier, so renewal will come down to product and price
- Precedents of European governments choosing to replace Palantir are spreading: Germany's military platform excludes Palantir, France has Arcadia, the Netherlands is seeking a European alternative within two years, and Sweden has Nordan AI
- The deeper the platform sits in the strike process, the harder it is to shed responsibility when something goes wrong
- Maven's political risk is rising: it has just become a formal programme, and after the midterms Democrats will press harder on accountability
- Room for growth in Palantir's international government business has to be revised down
Sources 5
- Computer Weekly, 20 Nov: NHS debate
- UK House of Commons debate record, 17 Nov
- Stars and Stripes, 19 Nov: Maven accountability
- Bloomberg, 17 Nov: Vals tests
- Expressen, 19 Nov: Nordan AI