Stray Dog

Skip discounted cash flow

$27 a share
$53 a share
13% growth, 10% discount rate17% growth, 8% discount rate
13% growth, 10% discount rate$27 a share
17% growth, 8% discount rate$53 a share

It is perfect in theory, but it needs a forecast of the next five to ten years, and nobody can make one

The reasoning

Small changes in the guesses swing the answer: move the growth guess 2 points either way and the discount rate, the return you demand, 1 point, and the same share is worth anywhere from $27 to $53. So we use ranges and scenarios instead, which make you say how sure you are and how bad it could get.