Stray Dog

Meta Muse: weak agent demand and rising blocks

  • Bad news: In Halloween week, third-party AI agents booked only 4 Uber rides and about 500 food deliveries, so demand looks weak.
  • Bad news: Notre Dame banned new Muse connections to university Google accounts pending a security and privacy review.
  • Bad news: Google launched checkout inside Gemini in Canada, one of the first two markets where Muse launched.
Read the full notes

A weaker day for the thesis. Distribution is being stepped up (social sharing), but evidence of demand stays weak: first-hand data from DoorDash and Uber shows agent orders close to zero. Institutional blocks have spread from bank and retail to university work accounts, and Google is entering checkout with its wallet. For the thesis to hold, Meta must show high-retention usage data beyond shopping.

Key evidence

  • Uber Q3 earnings call, 4 Nov (relayed by TechCrunch and The Verge): in Halloween week Uber and Uber Eats handled about 320 million orders in total, and third-party AI agents booked only 4 rides and about 500 food deliveries.
  • An analyst specifically asked about the Muse opportunity on the call. Uber gave only a combined figure for all agents and did not break out Muse.
  • Khosrowshahi: a ride takes 50 seconds on average to book in the app and a repeat food order 90 seconds, so agents save no time. There are about 8 mainstream assistants, soon more than 10, and Uber does not want to depend on any one of them.
  • Last week DoorDash had a cumulative few hundred orders, and Uber a similar number. Personal agents cannot replace high-frequency tasks that the app has already optimised to the limit.
  • Meta's own data: more than 25% of users have used the shopping feature, with an average order value above $200.
  • Notre Dame AI office notice (ai.nd.edu, around 4 Nov): existing faculty and staff can no longer connect Muse to their university Google accounts, and all new connections are banned pending a security and privacy review.
Show 6 more
  • The notice directly cites reports that Muse share links leak sensitive information and that its permissions are too broad.
  • Meta's head of security, Stamos, said publicly the same day that handing login credentials to Muse is completely crazy.
  • On 4 Nov Google launched checkout directly inside Gemini in Canada (CBC, interview with Eric Morris). It uses Google Wallet payment and address details, and the retailer is the seller and is responsible for fulfilment.
  • The first partners are Lululemon, Shoppers Drug Mart, Simons and some Shopify merchants. Integration is free for retailers.
  • Canada is one of the first two markets where Muse launched. Shopify supplies both Muse and Google.
  • Alexandr Wang, Meta's chief AI officer, announced on 3 Nov (relayed by Lapaas) that Muse character dance animations can be shared to Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp in one tap. Users with a linked Instagram account can generate them directly in Stories.

Catalysts to watch

  • Whether Meta can disclose high-retention usage data beyond shopping
  • Whether the institutional block at Notre Dame spreads to more universities and companies
  • The effect of Google Gemini checkout in Canada on Muse's share
  • Actual data on new users from sharing Muse dance animations on social media

Risks

  • Agent orders at DoorDash and Uber are close to zero, which shows personal agents cannot replace high-frequency tasks
  • Platforms treat several agents as interchangeable channels and press them on terms (Uber said plainly it does not want to depend on any one)
  • Institutional blocks have spread from banks and retail to university work accounts, limiting Muse's penetration of the workplace
  • Google holds both shopping intent (search) and payment credentials (wallet), and is competing head on for the position of cross-site checkout
  • Privacy and reputation problems keep growing (share-link leaks, Stamos's public criticism)

Sources 4

  1. Uber Q3 earnings call, 4 Nov, relayed by TechCrunch and The Verge
  2. Notre Dame AI office notice, ai.nd.edu, around 4 Nov
  3. CBC, 4 Nov (Google Gemini checkout in Canada)
  4. Alexandr Wang announcement, 3 Nov, relayed by Lapaas (dance animation sharing)