Meta's Muse enters Mexico, but payment errors persist
- Good news: Muse launched in Mexico on 5 Nov, its fifth market and first in Latin America, usable directly inside WhatsApp.
- Bad news: CNET's test found errors at payment: a $22.75 quote was charged as $23.35, and a membership was signed up against instructions.
- Bad news: Video avatars add compute cost per user, while Zuckerberg has said profit depends on cutting compute costs.
Read the full notes
Today's verdict is neutral. Distribution keeps expanding: Mexico is the fifth market and the first in Latin America, and going straight in through WhatsApp tests the claim that distribution is Meta's core advantage. The product is also getting deeper, with real-time voice and animated avatars now fully available in the US.
Read more
But neither of the two core problems has improved. (1) Transaction reliability: CNET's test found repeated errors at the most sensitive step, payment. Muse signed up for an Instacart Plus membership against the user's instructions, quoted $22.75 but charged $23.35, and got stuck on a design task for several minutes before the tester switched to ChatGPT. Muse wants to earn money from transaction fees, which only works if users dare to hand it their money. (2) Compute cost per user: video avatars burn extra compute for every user, and with 10 million users and 1% on a video call at once, about 8,300 GB200s would be needed. Zuckerberg has said Muse can only make money by driving compute costs down, and this feature pushes the other way. OpenAI's decision to keep Dots out of the free mass market (enterprise and Pro subscribers first) itself suggests that free personal agents are hard to make pay. Muse's free window is in Meta's hands, but that also underlines how hard the business model is.
Key evidence
- Mexico launched on 5 Nov (Infobae and El Universal relaying Meta's announcement): the first country in Latin America, in Spanish, 18+, on iOS, Android and muse.ai, and usable directly inside WhatsApp. It is free with an optional paid subscription
- First connected merchants: Cinépolis (cinemas), Coppel and Liverpool (retail), Despegar (travel), Kavak (used cars), Kueski (consumer lending) and Rappi (delivery). 'Credit and lending' appears as a category for the first time, and some connections are being opened 'gradually'
- Current markets: the US, Canada, Japan, Singapore and Mexico (the fifth)
- Meta's official press release of 5 Nov (about.fb.com): real-time voice conversation is now open to everyone in the US on phone, web and Mac. Users can interrupt, there are several hundred voices, and the avatar's expressions follow the conversation
- Glasses and the Muse Charm pendant are only said to be 'coming soon', with no date (the weekly report records a plan for glasses in November)
- Technical figures from Meta's research blog: about 870 milliseconds from the end of the user's speech to the first byte. The model was distilled from 120 computations to 2 (a 60-fold cut), serving capacity is 8 times the baseline, and one GB200 can run 12 real-time video streams
Show 4 more
- Rough compute estimate: 10 million users × 1% on a video call at once ÷ 12 streams per GB200 about 8,300 GB200s
- CNET test, 5 Nov: Instacart blocked access without a login and needed a manual takeover. Instacart Plus was signed up for even though the tester said no membership (later cancelled). It quoted $22.75 but charged $23.35. A design task for a wrapping-paper card stalled for several minutes and the tester switched to ChatGPT
- OpenAI Dots, 5 Nov (Fortune): available only to US enterprise and Pro subscribers at first. Huet, head of developer experience, hinted that a rival has 'a good interface but can do fairly basic things'. Fortune says Muse got there first and is very popular with consumers. OpenAI admits Dots is 'compute-heavy' and some tasks are moved to smaller models
- Musk said on 1 Nov that the Grok Bot's costs are unsustainable (indirect support)
Catalysts to watch
- Real usage data from the WhatsApp entry point in Mexico (how deep merchant connections go once they are 'gradually' opened)
- The actual date for real-time voice on glasses and the Muse Charm pendant (planned for November)
- Better transaction reliability in Muse (agent order volumes on Instacart, Uber, DoorDash and others)
- A path to lower compute cost per user (Zuckerberg has said profit depends on it)
- Whether OpenAI Dots eventually enters the free mass market
Risks
- Errors in transactions steadily wear down trust (ignored instructions, mismatched quote and charge), and the business model rests on that trust
- The video avatar feature adds to compute costs when the profit path requires Zuckerberg to cut them
- Unit economics of free personal agents are hard to make work (OpenAI and xAI are both avoiding the free mass market)
- Whether the distribution advantage can really turn into transaction frequency (WhatsApp entry point vs the few agent orders seen in testing)
- 'Credit and lending' appears in Mexico for the first time, and regulatory and risk controls need extra follow-up
Sources 5
- Infobae / El Universal (5 Nov): Muse launches in Mexico
- Meta official press release, about.fb.com (5 Nov): real-time voice and animated avatars in the US
- Meta research blog: distillation figures (870ms, 120 to 2 computations, 12 video streams on one GB200)
- CNET (5 Nov): test of Muse on a birthday task
- Fortune (5 Nov): OpenAI Dots launch