Stray Dog

Starship Flight 15: ship reaches orbit, booster explodes

  • Good news: The ship reached orbit for the second time and deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites, taking the V3 total to 52.
  • Bad news: Super Heavy booster B22 aborted and exploded; no V3 booster has been recovered, so full reuse is unproven.
  • Bad news: Two Democratic senators wrote to demand Starshield documents on Ukraine be preserved, a priority for the new Congress in January.
Read the full notes

On Starship's 15th flight the ship reached orbit for the second time and deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites (52 in total, adding a theoretical 26 Tbps). But the Super Heavy booster B22 aborted automatically and exploded, a V3 booster has still not been recovered, and full reuse is unproven.

Read more

The key test for cutting launch costs by an order of magnitude comes tomorrow morning, with the upper stage's tower catch. The FCC approved 36 new-generation gateway stations to support V3 ground backhaul. The Starshield speed-limit row in Ukraine has escalated: Democrats Shaheen and Coons wrote to demand preservation of documents (a priority for the new Congress in January). Starlink is shifting from remote areas to door-to-door sales in suburbs to win customers from cable and fibre. The purchase of 1,200 acres near Starbase has been put on hold by new Texas governor Hinojosa during the transition and pulled from the November agenda. Rival Amazon Leo's first Vulcan launch has slipped a day.

Key evidence

  • Starship's 15th flight launched from Starbase at 17:48 US-China time on 13 Nov (Spaceflight Now, Ars Technica)
  • The Super Heavy booster B22 triggered an automatic abort, diverted to the Gulf of Mexico and exploded before splashdown; the tower catch was cancelled and no official reason was given
  • Ship S42 was cleared to fire into orbit, its second time in Earth orbit; SpaceX on X confirmed all 26 Starlink V3 satellites reached orbit
  • V3 total is 52 (adding the 26 from Flight 14); by design each gives about 1 Tbps downlink, so this batch adds a theoretical 26 Tbps
  • S42 is due to return after about 22 hours in orbit, with a tower catch at about 5:17 Singapore time on 15 Nov; 3 of the satellites carry cameras to inspect the heat shield
  • The FCC approved 36 earth station applications from SpaceX Services by order on 12 Nov (the commission's daily digest; PCMag, 13 Nov: new-generation gateways supporting gigabit speeds)
Show 10 more
  • Zelensky said on 13 Nov that restrictions on Starshield terminals at the front have still not been lifted (Washington Post); SpaceX had denied any change on 12 Nov
  • Senate Foreign Relations Committee Democrats Shaheen and Coons wrote to Musk demanding that all documents and communications on Starlink/Starshield in Ukraine be preserved (first reported by the Wall Street Journal, followed by Bloomberg)
  • Democrats hold at least 8 more Senate seats, and say it will be a priority once the new Congress sits in January
  • SpaceX has newly hired field sales representatives for a Starlink door-to-door sales programme (PCMag, 13 Nov)
  • For comparison: new users in big cities are offered prices at 30-50% of the usual level, and Ookla shows urban growth more than 2 times rural, so customer acquisition is moving from remote areas to suburbs to take share from cable and fibre
  • SpaceX statement of 13 Nov: it plans to buy about 1,200 acres of state park land next to the Starbase launch site (mainly mudflats and dunes), with a permanent conservation easement on 600 acres, and excluding Boca Chica beach
  • Governor-elect of Texas Hinojosa has formally asked the Texas Parks and Wildlife Commission to hold off on the sale during the transition, and the item has been pulled from the commission's November agenda (Texas Tribune)
  • This is the second time Starbase expansion has run into the new state government (earlier over a gas power plant and a supercomputing campus)
  • ULA's Vulcan rocket cancelled its 13 Nov launch over a liquid nitrogen supply problem and is rescheduled for 17:32 UTC on 14 Nov (1:32 Singapore time on 15 Nov), carrying 40 Amazon Leo satellites, Vulcan's return to flight after a nine-month grounding (Spaceflight Now, ULA website)
  • The latest 8-K on EDGAR is still the one from 6 Nov; on 13 Nov there was only an institutional shareholder 13G/A holdings filing, with no new operating data

Catalysts to watch

  • 5:17 Singapore time on 15 Nov: tower catch of the S42 upper stage (the next key test)
  • Recovery of a V3 Super Heavy booster on the next flight (a key step to full reuse)
  • Starshield hearings moving forward after the new Congress sits in Jan 2027
  • The next 8-K or quarterly operating data
  • When the 1,200-acre Starbase deal returns to the Texas parks commission agenda
  • Average revenue per user (ARPU) and acquisition costs in later results: the return on suburban door-to-door sales

Risks

  • No V3 Super Heavy booster has yet been recovered: full reuse is unproven, and the core thesis of cutting launch costs by an order of magnitude is undelivered
  • The specific reason for booster B22's automatic abort and explosion has not been made public
  • Congressional oversight and hearing risk for Starshield is rising (for now only document preservation, not a formal investigation)
  • Higher customer acquisition costs from suburban door-to-door sales could squeeze Starlink margins
  • Starbase expansion has been blocked by a new state government for the second time: Texas's political climate is turning against SpaceX
  • A successful Vulcan return to flight for Amazon Leo would compete directly with Starlink's low-Earth-orbit capacity

Sources 9

  1. Spaceflight Now and Ars Technica (Starship Flight 15)
  2. SpaceX account on X (confirmation of V3 in orbit)
  3. FCC daily digest, 12 Nov, and PCMag, 13 Nov (gateway stations)
  4. Washington Post (Zelensky on Starshield speed limits)
  5. Wall Street Journal and Bloomberg (Shaheen/Coons letter)
  6. PCMag, 13 Nov (Starlink door-to-door hiring)
  7. SpaceX statement of 13 Nov and Texas Tribune (Starbase land)
  8. ULA website and Spaceflight Now (Vulcan return to flight)
  9. SEC EDGAR 8-K of 6 Nov and 13G/A of 13 Nov